Narcissistic Process and Corporate Decay: The Theory of the Organizational Ideal

TitleNarcissistic Process and Corporate Decay: The Theory of the Organizational Ideal
Pub. Year1990
AuthorsSchwartz, H
PublisherNYU Press
Keywordsbureaucracy, conformity, creativity, environment, false self, individuality, meaning, organizational totalitarianism, performance, psychic prison, rank, ritual, role
Links
Notes

environment, ritual

"When work, the productive process, becomes display, its meaning becomes lost. Its performance as part of the organizational drama becomes the only meaning it has. Accordingly, the parts it plays in the organization's transactions with the world become irrelevant. When this happens, work loses its adaptive function and becomes mere ritual. At the same time, the rituals that serve to express the individual's identification with the organization ideal, especially those connected with rank, come to be infused with significance for the individual. They become sacred. Thus, reality and appearance trade places. The energy that once went into the production of goods and services of value to others is channelled into the dramatization of a narcissistic fantasy in which the organization's environment is merely a stage setting." (p. 61)

conformity

Loss of Creativity
"The delegitimation of one's sense of what is important gives rise to a special case of the ritualization of work--the loss of creativity. Schein (1983) describes the condition of 'conformity' that follows from an insistence by the organization that all of its norms be accepted as being equally important. Under that condition, the individual 'can tune in so completely on what he sees to be the way others are handling themselves that he becomes a carbon-copy and sometimes a caricature of them.' Consequently, Schein notes: 'The conforming individual curbs his creativity and thereby moves the organization toward a sterile form of bureaucracy.' " (p. 63)

organizational totalitarianism

"This is the fundamental dynamic of totalitarianism. It alienates people from themselves and gives them over to others. Whatever victories ensue must be pyrrhic. Whatever happiness is to be attained here is not the happiness of the individual. Indeed, it is not happiness at all. It is the drama of happiness attaching to a role that the person performs in a play that is written and directed by others." (p. 16)


References

  1. [Bly1996] Bly, C.  1996.  Changing the Bully Who Rules the World: Reading and Thinking about Ethics.
  2. [Coens2000] Coens, T, Jenkins M.  2000.  Abolishing Performance Appraisals: Why They Backfire and What to Do Instead.
  3. [Collins1994] Collins, J, Porras JI.  1994.  Built to Last: Successful Habits of Visionary Companies.
  4. [French1998] French, WL, Bell CH.  1998.  Organization Development : Behavioral Science Interventions for Organization Improvement.
  5. [Hyatt1987] Hyatt, C, Gottlieb L.  1987.  When Smart People Fail.
  6. [Jones1989] Jones, BG.  1989.  A Fight to a Better End.
  7. [Kantrow1988] Kantrow, AM.  1988.  The Constraints of Corporate Tradition: Doing the Correct Thing Not Just What the Past Dictates.
  8. [Kohler1992] Kohler, H.  1992.  Kohler Economics.
  9. [Mackay1989] Mackay, HB.  1989.  Swim with the Sharks Without Being Eaten Alive.
  10. [Michael2] Mueller, M, Groff JR, Weinberg PN.  2002.  SQL: The Complete Reference, Second Edition [With CDROM].
  11. [Muchinsky1996] Muchinsky, PM.  1996.  Psychology Applied to Work: An Introduction to Industrial and Organizational Psychology.
  12. [ONeil2003] O'Neil, W.  2003.  Business Leaders and Success: 55 Top Business Leaders and How They Achieved Greatness.
  13. [Peters1987] Peters, T.  1987.  Thriving on Chaos.
  14. [Randall1967] Randall, CB.  1967.  Managers for Tomorrow : A Modern Psychological Approach to the Managerial Process.
  15. [Rosenbluth1994] Rosenbluth, H.  1994.  The Customer Comes Second.
  16. [Smith2000] Smith, G.  2000.  Work Rage: Identify the Problems, Implement the Solutions.
  17. [Welch2001] Welch, J, Byrne JA.  2001.  Jack: Straight from the Gut.
  18. [Dyer1978] Dyer, WW.  1978.  Pulling Your Own Strings : Dynamic Techniques for Dealing with Other People and Living Your Life as You Choose.
  19. [Rees1991] Rees, F.  1991.  How to Lead Work Teams: Facilitation Skills.